Whispers and Shadows - Indigenous Presence and Erasure in Australian Film of the 1940s and 1950s
The post-World War II era in Australian cinema presents a complex and often contradictory landscape regarding the representation of Indigenous Australians. While the dominant narrative frequently marginalized or stereotyped Indigenous people, the nascent, and often overlooked, contributions of Indigenous filmmakers themselves offer a crucial counter-narrative. Foremost among these pioneering figures is Bill Onus, whose untitled 1946 documentary footage stands as a monumental, albeit long-obscured, achievement. This chapter will explore key films of the 1940s and 1950s, including Harry Watt’s The Overlanders (1946), Eureka Stockade (1949), Ralph Smart’s Bitter Springs (1950), and Charles Chauvel’s Jedda (1955), while placing particular emphasis on the groundbreaking significance of Onus’s work.
Harry Watt’s 1946 production, The Overlanders, while seemingly progressive for its inclusion of Indigenous actors Henry Murdoch, Clyde Combo, and Bill Onus in speaking roles, warrants a more nuanced critique. While these actors were given screen time and dialogue, their characters were ultimately defined by their utility to the white protagonists’ survival. Their knowledge of the land, their tracking skills, and their physical labor were essential to the success of the cattle drive. This reinforces a colonial trope of the "helpful native," whose value is contingent upon their service to the white agenda. The anecdote about Murdoch carrying Shakespeare, while intended to humanize him, could also be interpreted through a paternalistic lens – the "noble savage" possessing an unexpected connection to Western culture, thus making him more palatable to a white audience. Were their own cultural knowledge systems and intellectual traditions given equal weight or recognition? The film, despite its surface-level inclusivity, ultimately reinforces a hierarchy where Indigenous expertise is instrumental but subordinate to white leadership and goals.
The rediscovery of Bill Onus’s untitled 1946 documentary footage is a profoundly significant event, offering a crucial disruption to the dominant narrative. As detailed in the documentary Ablaze (2021) and reported by ABC News, the fact that the first known film by an Indigenous Australian filmmaker remained lost for decades speaks volumes about the systemic neglect and erasure of Indigenous voices within the Australian film industry and broader society. This absence is not merely accidental; it reflects a historical context where Indigenous perspectives were actively suppressed or deemed irrelevant. The footage found which was filmed was of a theatre production called White Justice which was based in the 1946 Aboriginal strike in the Pilbara and was produced by the Melbourne New Theatre and the Australian Aboriginal League.
The act of Onus creating a "drama" – a constructed narrative – suggests a deliberate move beyond passive representation as subjects of a white gaze. It speaks to a desire to articulate Indigenous experiences, perspectives, and stories on their own terms, potentially challenging the often-simplistic and dehumanizing portrayals prevalent in mainstream media of the time. The ongoing efforts to understand and contextualize this footage are vital in reclaiming a lost history and acknowledging Indigenous agency in early filmmaking. The documentary Ablaze serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of archival research and the need to actively seek out and amplify marginalized voices.
In 1947, the non-Indigenous director Lee Robinson captured the life and art of Albert Namajira in the documentary Namatjira the Painter (1947). Robinson also cast Namatjira in a small role in the film The Phantom Stockman (1953) with Chips Rafferty.
The uncredited appearance of Henry Murdoch in Eureka Stockade (1949), another Harry Watt-directed Ealing Studios production, further underscores the precarious and often invisible position of Indigenous actors. Their presence, even in films depicting significant moments in Australian history, was often deemed inconsequential enough to warrant exclusion from the credits. This act of omission reflects a broader societal indifference to Indigenous contributions and a refusal to acknowledge their integral role in the nation’s story, even when that story involved conflict and dispossession..
Ralph Smart’s Bitter Springs (1950), also an Ealing Studios production featuring Henry Murdoch (credited) and around 50 uncredited Indigenous actors including Steve Dodd, while lauded for its attempt to address the issue of settler encroachment and its inclusion of the Pitjantjatjarra language, still operates within the framework of a white-authored narrative. As noted by Liz McNiven in her curation notes for the Australian Screen Online, the focus remains on the moral awakening of the white protagonist, Wally King (Chips Rafferty), and his decision to adopt a more conciliatory approach. While the film’s advocacy for negotiation and resource sharing was progressive for its time, it ultimately positions the white man as the arbiter of justice and the one who grants Indigenous people the right to exist and work on their own land. The rewritten ending, while avoiding a massacre, still reinforces a paternalistic dynamic where Indigenous survival and well-being are dependent on the goodwill of the white settlers. The uncredited presence of around 50 Indigenous actors, while providing a powerful visual representation of the community, also raises questions about their agency and compensation. Were they fairly remunerated? Were their perspectives on the story sought or valued beyond their physical presence? The film, despite its positive intentions, risks perpetuating a narrative where Indigenous people are acted upon rather than acting as agents of their own destiny. The provided clips from the film further illustrate the dynamics between the white settlers and the Indigenous community, prompting critical analysis of the performances and the framing of these relationships.
Charles Chauvel’s Jedda (1955), also released under the title Jedda - the Uncivilised, represents a significant step forward in terms of casting Indigenous actors Ngarla Kunoth and Robert Tudawali in leading roles and focusing the narrative on an Indigenous protagonist. Kunoth’s powerful performance as Jedda and Tudawali’s compelling portrayal of Marbuck brought Indigenous talent and stories to the forefront of Australian cinema in an unprecedented way. The film’s exploration of cultural identity and the devastating consequences of forced assimilation were groundbreaking for their time. However, a sensitive analysis must also acknowledge the limitations inherent in a film directed by a non-Indigenous filmmaker. While Chauvel’s intentions may have been progressive, the narrative is ultimately filtered through a white lens. The tragic ending, where Jedda and Marbuck are depicted as succumbing to their “primitive instincts,” can be interpreted as reinforcing colonial stereotypes about the inherent “savagery” of Indigenous people and the impossibility of bridging the cultural divide. The very title Jedda - the Uncivilised reveals the underlying colonial assumptions about Indigenous culture as being inherently inferior to white civilization.
The decades of obscurity surrounding Onus’s work are deeply telling. This absence underscores the systemic biases and historical amnesia that have characterized the Australian film industry and broader society’s engagement with Indigenous culture. The fact that the first Indigenous-directed film remained lost for so long highlights the urgent need for continued archival research and a commitment to decentering dominant historical narratives. The tireless efforts of Tiriki Onus, Bill’s grandson, and Alec Morgan in uncovering and bringing this history to light through the documentary Ablaze are not just acts of film historical recovery; they are acts of cultural reclamation and intergenerational connection. They serve as a powerful reminder that Indigenous histories and creative contributions are not relics of the past but living legacies that continue to shape our understanding of the present. Bill Onus was not simply a filmmaker; he was a prominent Aboriginal activist and leader. His foray into filmmaking should be understood within the broader context of his lifelong commitment to fighting for Indigenous rights and self-determination. His engagement with the medium of film likely stemmed from a recognition of its power to shape public perception and to disseminate alternative narratives.
In conclusion, the cinema of the 1940s and 1950s in Australia reveals a complex and often contradictory landscape of Indigenous representation. While moments of visibility and even seemingly progressive portrayals existed in films like The Overlanders, Bitter Springs, and the landmark Jedda, they were frequently circumscribed by non-Indigenous perspectives, colonial tropes, and systemic erasure. The groundbreaking work of Bill Onus in 1946, though belatedly recognized, stands as a powerful reminder of Indigenous agency and the desire for self-representation. A sensitive and critical analysis of this era requires us to look beyond the surface-level inclusion and to interrogate the underlying power dynamics, narrative frameworks, and enduring legacies of these early cinematic encounters with Indigenous Australia. It necessitates a commitment to uncovering marginalized voices and challenging the dominant narratives that have historically shaped our understanding of Indigenous presence in film and media. Bill Onus’s pioneering work serves as an inspiration and a crucial reminder of the enduring importance of Indigenous self-representation in shaping a more just and truthful understanding of Australian history and identity.
Overall, the cinema of the 1940s and 1950s in Australia presents a contradictory landscape of visibility and erasure for Indigenous Australians. While mainstream productions like The Overlanders, Bitter Springs, and Jedda offered screen presence and sometimes engaged with Indigenous issues, these narratives were frequently filtered through a non-Indigenous lens, perpetuating colonial tropes and limiting the agency afforded to Indigenous actors within paternalistic frameworks. Against this backdrop, the groundbreaking, yet long-obscured, contribution of Bill Onus and his 1946 documentary footage emerges as a vital act of early Indigenous self-representation, directly challenging the systemic silencing of Indigenous voices. Modern Indigenous Australian perspectives critically assess this era for its reinforcement of harmful stereotypes and its centering of white narratives, even in seemingly progressive projects. Nevertheless, analyzing these films, particularly the pioneering work of Onus, remains crucial for understanding the historical context of Indigenous representation, acknowledging the early efforts towards self-determination, and tracing the ongoing struggle for narrative sovereignty in Australian cinema.
References
Chauvel, C. (Director) (1955) Jedda.
Eckersley, M. (2014, May 26). Australian Indigenous Drama on Film. Australian Indigenous Drama. Available from: https://australianindigenousdrama.blogspot.com/2014/05/australian-indigenous-drama-on-film.html
Griffiths, S. (2002). 'Representing the 'Other': Race, Gender and Nation in Australian Cinema'. In The Oxford Guide to Australian Film (pp. 165-184). Oxford University Press.
Krausz, P. (n.d.). Screening Indigenous Australia: An overview of Aboriginal representation on film. [online] Available at: https://kooriweb.org/foley/resources/media/indigenousfilm.pdf.
Smart, R. (Director) (1950) Bitter Springs. Ealing Studios.
Watt, H. (Director) (1946) The Overlanders.
Watt, H. (Director) (1949) Eureka Stockade. Ealing Studios.
Additional References
Ablaze (2021) Documentary.
Administration (2021). Was activist Bill Onus our first Aboriginal film-maker? [online] The Lighthouse. Available at: https://lighthouse.mq.edu.au/article/july-2021/was-activist-bill-onus-our-first-aboriginal-film-maker
Batty, P. (2007). Black Tracks: Contemporary Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Performance. University of Queensland Press.
Chauvel, C. (1956) Jedda: the uncivilised. Sydney: Scripts.
Gibson, R. (1992). 'The Passion of Dirk Hartog: Historical Archaeology, National Identity and Australian Film'. Continuum: Journal of Media & Cultural Studies, 5(2), 203-225.
Murray, S. (2007) The cinema of Australia. Eastgardens, NSW: McGraw-Hill Australia.
Pike, A. & Cooper, R. (1998) Australian film 1900-1977: A guide to feature film production. Revised edition. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
Reid, N. (2004) ‘Jedda’ in Australian cinema: pioneers, outsiders and rebels. St Leonards, NSW: Allen & Unwin, pp. 124-133.
Ryan, S. (2014, May 26). Australian Indigenous Drama on Film. Australian Indigenous Drama. Available from: https://australianindigenousdrama.blogspot.com/2014/05/australian-indigenous-drama-on-film.html
Shoemaker, A. (1998) ‘Film’ in A companion to Australian history. Edited by S. Foster & M. French. Melbourne: Oxford University Press, pp. 465-480.
Shoemaker, A. (2004). 'Representations of Aboriginal People in Australian Film'. In The Encyclopedia of Aboriginal Australia (Vol. 2, pp. 908-913). Aboriginal Studies Press.
Smith, R. (2002) Australian film. Melbourne: Schwartz Publishing.
Turner, G. (2006) Film as social practice. 4th edn. London: Routledge.
Williams, D. (1996) Indigenous Australians and the cinema. Cinema Papers no. 108, pp. 12-15
Williams, S. (2003) Ossie Davis Onscreen: Film and Television Performances. Palgrave Macmillan.
Wright, D. (2013) Charles Chauvel: Australia's first film-maker. North Sydney, NSW: Random House Australia.
Additional Academic Papers and Theses
Debenham, J.A. (2013) Representations of Aborigines in Australian Documentary Film 1901 - 2009. PhD thesis, University of Newcastle. Available from: https://nova.newcastle.edu.au/vital/access/services/Download/uon:13508/ATTACHMENT01
Frey, A. (2015) Eco-Fourth Cinema: Indigenous Rights and Environmental Crises. PhD thesis, University of Queensland. Available from: https://espace.library.uq.edu.au/view/UQ:f232a64/s4330872_final_thesis.pdf
Hampson, J. (2010) Reorienting the Feminine Other in Australian Film. BA thesis, University of Queensland. Available from: https://espace.library.uq.edu.au/view/UQ:3b58300/s44184267_final_thesis.pdf
Langton, M. (2003) Beyond the burden of history in Indigenous Australian cinema. Film Studies, 20(1), 36-53.